Atlas / Financial Services
Industry profile
Health Insurance marketing benchmarks
Strongest on Retention & Loyalty, weakest on Data & Tracking. Health Insurance sits above the national average, and that tension shapes how the whole industry markets.
Score signature
Bars are this industry. Ticks are the national average.
Biggest strength
Retention & Loyalty
70 out of 100. The engine carrying the whole score.
Biggest gap
Data & Tracking
54 out of 100. The dimension dragging the industry down.
Where to start
Data & Tracking
The most upside per point of effort: 5% of the score and 3 points below the field.
The map
Where this industry sits
Every dot is an industry we measure. Choose any two dimensions for the axes. Health Insurance is the red mark.
Acquisition Performance →
Health Insurance sits above average on Retention & Loyalty and above average on Acquisition Performance. That tension defines the industry.
The spread inside the industry
Every number is a Marketing Score out of 100. It rolls six dimensions into one figure, so 53 is a business doing the basics and 74 is one that markets like a business twice its size.
The distance between the strongest and weakest performer here is wide. A small cluster is genuinely good. A long tail sits well behind. The bar to lead this industry is lower than the reputation suggests. So where would you land?
The breakdown
How far above or below the field
Each row plots this industry against the whole field. The dot is where Health Insurance sits, the line is the national average and the faint marks are every other industry. Tap a row for what the dimension means.
How modern and capable is the digital setup?
How well does the industry win new demand?
How well does it turn interest into customers?
How well does it keep and grow customers?
How clear and distinct is the brand?
Can any of this actually be measured?
The read
What the numbers say about Health Insurance
On the whole, Health Insurance is an above-average industry. It leads on retention & loyalty and trails on data & tracking, and the fastest gains sit in data & tracking.
Retention & Loyalty
Sits in the leading group of every industry we measure. This is the engine carrying the score.
Data & Tracking
Sits in the lower half. The soft spot that drags the whole number down.
Data & Tracking
Carries the most weight in the score and sits below the field. Move this and the whole number moves with it.
A retention & loyalty-led industry with a data & tracking problem. The reputation says one thing. The pipeline says another.
Go deeper
Marketing a product Australians love to hate+
Health insurance is one of the most disliked product categories in Australia. Annual premium increases, complex policies, exclusion periods and claims disputes generate consistent negative sentiment. Yet 44% of Australians hold private health cover. The composite reflects an industry that markets effectively despite this headwind.
Retention is the anchor, and for good reason. Losing a member after five years of premium payments means losing the return on a $300-$800 acquisition cost plus the margin that was just beginning to compound. The top-performing funds (Medibank, HCF, HBF) invest heavily in member experience: digital claims, optical and dental networks, wellness programs and proactive communication.
Acquisition with 25% weight is dominated by three channels: comparison sites (iSelect, Compare the Market, Canstar), direct digital campaigns targeting the under-30 LHC cohort and corporate group schemes. The funds that win on acquisition have streamlined the comparison and sign-up process to reduce the friction of switching.
The brand challenge is structural. Health insurance is a grudge purchase. Nobody is excited to pay their premium. The brands that have shifted the narrative from "insurance you have to have" to "a health partner that helps you live better" score above the mean. HCF's "uncommon care" positioning and Medibank's wellness focus are examples of this reframing.
Digital maturity reflects significant investment in online self-service. Digital claims, policy management, provider search and hospital gap estimators have become table stakes. The funds still relying on phone-based service for routine transactions are losing younger members to digitally-native competitors like those offering fully app-based health cover.
Retention-anchored in a grudge purchase category+
Retention carries 25% and scores 69.6. Health insurance is the definition of a retention business. Acquiring a member costs $300-$800. The margin on that member builds over years. Every year of retention compounds value.
Acquisition at 25% reflects the constant need to grow membership, driven by competitive pressure, the PHI rebate and the lifetime health cover loading that incentivises under-30s to join.
Brand at 5% is the lowest weight, which seems wrong for a category where brand trust matters enormously. The low weight reflects that brand impact is mediated through retention (trusted brands retain) and acquisition (trusted brands attract). The direct brand measure captures positioning clarity.
Where health insurers should focus+
Retention is strong but the cost of failure is high. A 1% improvement in retention for a major health fund translates to millions in lifetime value retained. Claims experience, digital self-service, communication clarity and extras utilisation all drive retention.
Brand is the weakest dimension and the trust challenge. Australian consumers distrust health insurers. Premium increases, exclusions and claims knockbacks drive negative sentiment. The brands investing in transparency, claims simplification and proactive communication are rebuilding trust.
Conversion with 20% weight can improve in the comparison and switching process. The funds that make it easy to compare, easy to understand what is covered and easy to switch capture more of the switching pool.
Highlighted terms link through to the marketing dictionary.
In context
Where it sits in Financial Services
Frequently asked
Common questions about Health Insurance
How do Australian health insurers compare on marketing?+
What drives health insurance customer retention?+
How do health insurers acquire new members?+
Why is brand trust low for health insurers?+
Keep exploring
Where to go from here
Pull any thread.
Same sector
Superannuation & Wealth Management
Above average overall. Strongest on Digital.
Open the profile